A Sundae Ain’t a Sundae Without a Cherry
Book Review: Magnetic City

The maraschino cherry — oozing, dyed, saturated with sugar and who knows what else — completes a sundae in ways that fudge, sprinkles, caramel, chopped walnuts, and whipped cream can’t. There simply isn’t an ice cream capstone, whether it achieves visual or taste perfection, like the cherry.
A sundae just ain’t a sundae without a cherry on top.
Such is how I felt about the glaring absence of a dedicated Lower East Side walk, aka the cherry, from Magnetic City: A Walking Companion to New York, Justin Davidson’s otherwise well-constructed, thoughtful, informative, and thoroughly enjoyable book on New York City.
The work combines history, architecture, and personal observation through seven walks: the Financial District; the World Trade Center; the Seaport and Brooklyn waterfront; Chelsea and the High Line; 42nd Street; the Upper West Side; and the South Bronx and Sugar Hill.
It’s a useful reference and a fun way to think about meandering through the Big Apple while taking in its past and present. Davidson provides historical context alongside the vocabulary to describe what we’re seeing: rooflines, structures, ornament, and the details on facades that we might otherwise pass without noticing.
The 1991 movie The Fisher King, with Jeff Bridges and Robin Williams, actually has a line that I often quote in this regard: “Thank God nobody looks up in this town,” says Bridges, as his character, Jack Lucas, attempts a risky maneuver high in the sky. It’s a truism about New Yorkers, and perhaps all people, that we often are so fixated on or preoccupied with what is right in front of us that we miss the wonder above our heads.
Nevertheless, Davidson’s walking history provides an antidote to this tendency, as he illuminates what stands (or stood) from eye level up to the clouds along each route.
In the Financial District, for instance, he points out how the slope toward Pearl Street preserves a clue to Manhattan’s original shoreline, now dry and held inland by generations of landfill. Near Fraunces Tavern — still a great spot for a drink — the contemporary street gives us a way to imagine the waterfront of New Amsterdam. He also recounts how the Great Fire of 1835 swept through Lower Manhattan while the East River was frozen and firefighting pumps seized up. The ensuing destruction helped spur stronger fire codes and a more reliable water supply.
These are the kinds of details I appreciate: a reason to stop at an otherwise unremarkable corner and consider what used to be there, what remains, and why.
One of my more interesting takeaways was how the city has accommodated wealth — and how our idea of what wealth looks like has changed. On the Upper West Side, private mansions and townhouses gave way to another means of expressing personal affluence: opulent apartment buildings that brought wealthy households together under one roof. By the 1920s and ’30s, buildings such as the San Remo offered expansive apartments, prestigious addresses, and prominent neighbors — among them the families of future photographer Diane Arbus and composer Stephen Sondheim, who grew up in the same building.
Height added another dimension. Increasingly, exclusivity could be measured by how far above everyone else you lived. Today’s exceptionally slender towers and hundredth-floor penthouses overlooking Central Park take that idea to a literal conclusion. (See #PH88 in the troubled 432 Park Avenue building for a contemporary example.)
Running through all of this is a larger question: what and how much should a city preserve?
This inquiry, which surfaces toward the book’s end, conveniently connects with another book I’ve read (and that we’ve covered here), Vanishing New York, by Jeremiah Moss. Davidson invokes Moss toward the end, setting his resistance to the city’s losses against Nikolai Fedak, founder of New York YIMBY, who champions growth, development, and the city’s capacity to reinvent itself.
As I read the contrast, Moss is concerned with what gets displaced: residents, independent businesses, communities, and the particular character that made a neighborhood worth caring about in the first place. The opposing argument emphasizes the opportunities that change makes possible. Davidson claims a position somewhere between them, attentive to both the value of what survives and the necessity of making room for what comes next.
Davidson’s upbringing in Rome — another surprising and fascinating nugget — added another dimension to his position. He contends that we like to imagine Rome as enduring, almost fixed: antiquity standing around as modern life buzzes on past. But the Rome we encounter is actually the accumulated result of building, destruction, reuse, and rebuilding. Its apparent permanence obscures the changes that produced it.
Which brings me to the Lower East Side and the so-called cherry.
First, let’s point out that a person with the maturity level of a child is precisely the type to complain about a sundae lacking a cherry, or — in this case — that a fine book like Magnetic City omits the Lower East Side as a walk-worthy neighborhood.
Still, of the seven walks, the Lower East Side does not get more than mentions in passing.
I don’t know Davidson, and I’m not inclined to shake a fist because a book about New York failed to devote a walk to my neighborhood.
He obligatorily references tenements, immigrant households, and Five Points, as well as public housing, the Tenement Museum, and Corlears Hook. But those appearances left me wanting the sustained attention Davidson gives to other parts of the city.
Frankly, I would like to have that eighth walk with him to talk about the vestiges of former factories, schools, and houses of worship that remain, even if today’s residents only faintly resemble those buildings’ former occupants, if at all.
Still, Magnetic City encourages a slower, more attentive reading of streets and asks the questions that we should ask as we walk along Vernon Boulevard in Queens, Arthur Avenue in the Bronx, or Orchard Street here on the Lower East Side.
But instead of a cherry, we can top off our stroll with a full sour pickle — available and always delicious, at the Pickle Guys.



