Remembering: Kenny Shopsin
Neighbor Profile: More For LES

I’m a pizza ship*.
This vulgar and expletive-based description is, I presume, how short-order cook, fly-swatter, suspender-rocking, foul-mouthed philosopher, restaurateur, motorcyclist, and namesake of Shopsin’s General Store, Kenny Shopsin, would have referred to me.
If the name or the venue is unfamiliar, please join me on a brief pilgrimage as I review Matt Mahurin’s 2004 documentary, I Like Killing Flies. Today, Shopsin’s is an eatery on the Essex Street side of (the new) Essex Market, but its roots are steeped in the West Village.
Filmed in 2002 and 2003 and first shown at Sundance the next year, the story opens at a pivotal moment as the Shopsin family is pondering a move to a new location. For nearly three decades prior, the business had been at 63 Bedford Street, on the corner of Morton Street, having made not only a home in the space but having settled into its quirks and shortcomings — jerry-rigging stands for drying racks and coming up with solutions for ineffective or unreliable appliances.
I Like Killing Flies provides a glimpse into the mind and belief system of Kenny Shopsin, along with his loving but combative relationships with his wife, Eve; his three boys, Charles, Daniel, and Zack; and his twin daughters, Melinda and Tamara.
Kenny and Eve had opened the business as a grocery in 1973 and converted it into a restaurant in 1982. It’s in the film’s present day that, according to Kenny, the Shopsins have been given an opportunity to renew their lease for one year at market rent — an offer that, in his telling, suggested the landlord wanted to see a new tenant take over the lease.
Kenny and family were forced to think quickly, but the local patrons and neighborhood seemed to rally around them, and they were able to relocate to 54 Carmine Street, at Bedford Street, just around the way.
Notably, on the real estate front, Kenny cites a monthly rent of $6,500 in the film. At that time, $6,500/month for a 900-square-foot restaurant — which works out to less than $90 per square foot annually — seems like a lot, even for a corner location in the West Village. Today, a similar location would easily go for $350 per square foot annually, or more than $25,000/month, so it’s easy to appreciate the financial and emotional strain involved in not only making the decision, but also doing it under duress.
Through the telling of Shopsin’s story, we’re exposed to Kenny’s abrasive yet endearing and thoughtful approach, as well as his irascibility and his boorishness.
He likens his unusual combinations of food to anal sex — “like puttin’ your d*ck in the wrong hole.” But there’s obviously a softer side to the man, despite his rough edges. He gives his son, Zack, a stern talking to when the young man gets a parking ticket right under his nose for deprioritizing the one task — minding the meter — which had a deadline. Meanwhile, he also talks about treating people with respect even when they don’t deserve it, a practice that might have been more aspirational for the man.
And, of course, he notably likes killing flies, swatting them when he’s not celebrating their electrocution in a bug-zapper.
Kenny shares a story about a cockroach that was found in soup and how that was obviously terrible for the customer, but also something terrible for him. As you get to know Kenny a little, it’s fascinating that that cuts him as deeply as it does, and it shows how much he cares about what he’s doing.
We see, as well, his wife, Eve, as a counterpoint to him. She has a neutralizing and sweet quality, speaking to how they paired so well and raised five kids as part of the family restaurant. Sadly, she passed away before the film was completed.
Of the peculiarities, there’s a selection of novelty candy on offer to customers, and there’s a veritable display of tchotchkes and signs, mostly humorous and some offensive — at least for the faint-hearted. And then, of course, there’s Robert Hershon’s poem about a party of five and how parties of five are not welcome.
In brief, and to paraphrase “Party of Five”: it doesn’t matter if one of you offers to leave, or if you say you could split into a party of three and a party of two, or if the five of you come back tomorrow in Richard Nixon masks. You are… A PARTY OF FIVE.
Viewers get the sense that customers thrive on the duality of fear and love, along with an assortment of 138 soups — according to one count — with flavors like pistachio red chicken curry and Peruvian shrimp avocado, and dishes such as macaroni and cheese pancakes, that have them coming back. In its original incarnation, the menu ran to some 900 items.
After roughly three decades in its original location, Shopsin’s stayed on Carmine Street for only about four years, closing there in late 2006. It reopened in June 2007 inside the old Essex Street Market at 120 Essex Street, where it stayed for nearly 12 years.
In May of 2019, Shopsin’s reopened at 88 Essex Street. Kenny, however, didn’t live to see that move. But three of his children — Zack, Melinda, and Tamara — carried the restaurant forward.
Today, Shopsin’s is one of my favorite stalls within the new Essex Market, and it’s become a favorite spot for me to lunch with my mom.
Why, then, am I a pizza ship?
Well, according to Kenny, “The first duty of everybody in life is to realize that they’re a [pizza ship].”
One Saturday, I showed up with my wife, my two sons, and my mom. (If you’re counting, that is a party of five.)
And when I encountered Zack, whom I’ve gotten to know through Friday lunches with my mom, I was introduced to the poem. And I learned that we’d overstepped and gone wrong. Nearly all of the goodwill that my mother and I had built up, our months of becoming Friday regulars, had vanished.
And so I vowed, when I learned about the film, to go back and learn more about this place peppered with tchotchkes, where you pour your own water and coffee, where you wait longer than you want for the high-priced but very oversized plate of food that might include a sparkler skewering the bread, and where you wait for a check that comes with some sort of stomach-turning gummy candy.
Until I watched the film, though, I don’t think I appreciated the good fortune of the Lower East Side — and Essex Market, as well — to have one of New York City’s real and storied treasures. Surely, the West Village’s loss is our gain.
*Oh, and in case you haven’t decoded pizza ship yet, pizza ship = piece of sh*t.
You may also enjoy

In a Bit of a Pickle, but Also a Bialy
A Lower East Side local joins a neighborhood food tour, revisiting Essex Market, tenement history, Kossar's, Orchard Street and Rivington Street.


