Can Brooklyn break the Ridgewicks’ curse?

Haunted Homequest

January 4, 2026

It’s Day 3 of our Haunted Homequest, as we escape Castle Rock with the Ridgewicks in search of a home in New York.

After spending miserable lives in Maine — and not because Maine is anything other than magical, they’ve just had the misfortune of being cast in a Stephen King novel — the couple is looking to the Big Apple for a bite of the good life.

To them, New York represents opportunity, but also a chance to start again.

They have a budget of between $950,000 and $1,000,000 and they’re looking at five properties per day. So far, they’ve seen the Bronx; today, it’ll be Brooklyn.

Jump back to our preview edition here to see further criteria on the method and mortgage terms, or read on to see what their search yielded where Brooklyn’s at.

9511 Shore Road #205

Details: Gut-renovated two-bedroom residence with blonde hardwood floors, split air units, in-unit washer/dryer, and an eat-in kitchen with Bosch appliances. The primary bedroom features an en-suite bath with new tiling. 9511 Shore Road is a doorman building with a gym, package room, extra laundry facilities, and deeded parking.

List Price: $989,000
Bedrooms/Bathrooms: 2 BR/2 BA
Approx. Size: 1,000 SF

Monthly Carrying Charges: $809
Monthly Taxes: $455
Monthly Mortgage Payment: $4,835
Total Monthly Overhead: $6,100

Notes: This property has a bonus of being located near an NYC Ferry stop, giving residents an added sense of mobility.

428 East 9th Street #513

Details: Unit features European oak floors, oversized windows, in-unit washer/dryer, and mini-split heating/cooling. The kitchen is equipped with Fulgini Contract cabinetry, quartz countertops, and Blomberg/Fisher & Paykel appliances. Kensington Manor features a doorman, fitness center, yoga room, children’s play center, pet spa, and rooftop lounge with grill stations.

List Price: $970,000
Bedrooms/Bathrooms: 2 BR/2 BA
Approx. Size: Unknown

Monthly Carrying Charges: $554
Monthly Taxes: $957
Monthly Mortgage Payment: $4,742
Total Monthly Overhead: $6,254

445 Fifth Avenue #4H

Details: One-bedroom condo features engineered hardwood flooring, floor-to-ceiling windows, and a Bosch washer/dryer. Kitchen includes Lineadecor cabinetry, woodgrain stone countertops, and Bosch appliances. The Slope on Fifth offers a 24-hour doorman, residents’ lounge, game room, gym, business center, and furnished roof deck with grill station.

List Price: $988,000
Bedrooms/Bathrooms: 1 BR/1 BA
Approx. Size: 630 SF

Monthly Carrying Charges: $712
Monthly Taxes: $695
Monthly Mortgage Payment: $4,830
Total Monthly Overhead: $6,238

2800 East 29th Street #103

Details: Duplex condo with hardwood floors, split unit A/C, eat-in kitchen with stainless steel appliances, and a primary ensuite with jacuzzi tub. The lower level provides approximately 750 sq. ft. of flexible space. The building itself is a walk-up with a private backyard, one deeded parking space, and two deeded storage units.

List Price: $989,000
Bedrooms/Bathrooms: 3 BR/2 BA
Approx. Size: 1,900 SF

Monthly Carrying Charges: $445
Monthly Taxes: $868
Monthly Mortgage Payment: $4,835
Total Monthly Overhead: $6,149

221 Frost Street GARDEN-F

Details: Split-wing 2-bedroom condo features European white oak floors, floor-to-ceiling windows, central HVAC, and in-unit washer/dryer. Kitchen is equipped with Dekton countertops, Bertazzoni oven, and Fisher & Paykel refrigerator. The Elara is a boutique condominium with an elevator, private storage lockers, and video intercom system.

List Price: $995,000
Bedrooms/Bathrooms: 2 BR/1.5 BA
Approx. Size: Unknown

Monthly Carrying Charges: $312
Monthly Taxes: $721
Monthly Mortgage Payment: $4,864
Total Monthly Overhead: $5,898

Have the Ridgewicks found better options in Brooklyn?