Farewell, LinkedIn. Sort Of.
Why I’m Rethinking My LinkedIn Newsletter and Bringing the Writing Home

Farewell, LinkedIn. Sort Of.
My newsletter never felt at home here. It didn’t feel seen, I guess. Really, though, it’s not just a feeling: the readership and engagement haven’t justified the effort.
Six months publishing a special newsletter for LinkedIn. Relative to the size of my network, a “respectable” number of people subscribed. (Thank you!) But I need to be ruthless in my decision-making.
The question is: Why swim upstream late in life only to find my way into the mouth of a hungry bear? I’m not a salmon!
Having nearly 10% of my overall connections as subscribers has been alluring, but perhaps I shouldn’t have taken the bait. Subscribers of free newsletters aren’t necessarily readers, nor are they necessarily people who are engaged in, thinking about, or responding directly to the work.
What I write matters.
I wouldn’t bother otherwise. My conviction, though, doesn’t obligate anyone to read. If they aren’t, I need to cast my line elsewhere, or at least evaluate whether the return is worth the effort.
Having spent years in SaaS, I followed Adam Robinson on LinkedIn. His shocking and untimely passing is tragic, and many have taken to LinkedIn to express their grief and loss in some way. He achieved something remarkable here: a distinctive voice, an attentive audience, and engagement that translated into business.
When I was involved with Pavilion, I took a class with Alec Paul, who helped Adam hone his approach. I had the opportunity to learn from someone behind that success, but that access hasn’t translated into similar results for my own writing.
That could be the means, the message, or some combination of the two. I don’t get to exempt the work itself from scrutiny. But I can decide where and how to concentrate it.
Adam’s success demonstrated what was possible on LinkedIn. Not every channel, though, is the right one for every business — including my own work in residential real estate.
Having spent years working in B2B SaaS, I cultivated many relationships with fellow professionals on LinkedIn, carving out a niche voice. Now that I’m building an uber-local real estate platform, I must distinguish between fresh and salt water.
A newsletter distributed through LinkedIn to business professionals, about the more personal side of my experience as an entrepreneur, has not really stood out in this somewhat brackish environment.
But it’s not just that the targeting and content probably have not resonated. It’s that this publishing practice isn’t supporting my larger objectives. After all, the body of my work lives on the More For LES website, MoreForLES.com.
That’s where I publish local research, real estate analysis, tools, commentary, and the ongoing account of our apartment renovation. The reflective essays live there, too. Essentially, what I’ve been doing is dual-publishing, posting the full content on both LinkedIn and my website.
That gives people two places to read the same essay, without giving me enough evidence that the second is worth the effort. Someone can read the full newsletter on LinkedIn without ever encountering the research, tools, and other work on my website.
There’s also a search consideration. When the same content appears on multiple sites, Google may choose which version to show. I’d rather post the full essays on my website and use LinkedIn to direct interested readers there.
I want more people to discover More For LES through search. I want someone with a question about the Lower East Side to find something I’ve written, use it, and have a reason to explore further. Concentrating my original work on my website supports that goal more directly than continuing to publish complete essays here.
That doesn’t guarantee Google will send readers my way. The writing still has to be useful, and people still have to want to read it. But it gives the effort a clearer purpose.
For anyone building a business, there’s a problem here that many of us can recognize. We start doing something for a reason. Then we repeat it often enough that the repetition becomes its own reason — a sort of muscle memory, or even the illusion that “doing” equates to progress. The notion of stopping feels like failure: the equivalent of “cutting bait” without any fish to show for it.
Yet there’s a difference between knowing that a platform can work and establishing that it works for you. Adam clearly found his audience on LinkedIn. Plenty of other people have, too. I can respect their success without treating it as an instruction to keep doing something that isn’t producing the results I need.
So the change is straightforward. I’ll continue to post on LinkedIn. Going forward, my newsletter here will include an excerpt and a link to the complete essay on More For LES.
For those who have been reading, thank you. Past and future essays will live (here) at moreforles.com, alongside the research, tools, and local perspectives that we provide. Beyond that, we’ll simply keep the waterways open.
You may also enjoy

Are You Mullet or Bandana-Rama?
A LinkedIn Original Publication

You’ve Got Mail! Building a Direct-Mail Campaign From Scratch
A LinkedIn Original Publication

Behind the Scenes: The Hidden Conversations of the Lower East Side
A LinkedIn Original Publication

Get Movin’: The Official More For LES Moving Guide





