One Manhattan Square: Primetime Above 40

Should Buyers Consider Purchasing at OMS?

July 11, 2025

The first property I’m looking at is One Manhattan Square (OMS).

OMS is an 80-story luxury condo located at 252 South Street on Manhattan’s Lower East Side waterfront. Developed by Extell and designed by Adamson Associates with interiors by Meyer Davis, the glass-clad skyscraper features 800+ residences with floor-to-ceiling windows and panoramic views of the East River, Midtown, and Brooklyn.

Residents enjoy over 100,000 square feet of resort-style amenities, including a spa, fitness center, pool, basketball and squash courts, bowling alley, and landscaped gardens by West 8.

Nearby transit hubs include the F train and the NYC Ferry. But I'm interested in more than the building's impressive profile and amenities. I want to answer a few questions:

  • Is OMS a good buy? If so, for whom?
  • Are there optimal units and floors? What is the premium?
  • What are the upsides? Downsides?

Let's start with the neighborhood before getting into the numbers.

Location, Location, Location — and a Few Other Considerations

Before the numeric deep dive, here’s what residents can find nearby:

Groceries: Brooklyn Fare is in the building — a 25,000+ sq ft full-service market. For the price-conscious and snackfood-sensitive, Trader Joe’s is a 10-minute walk, along with MetroAcres and the soon-to-open Lidl.

Schools & Daycare: The building is in NYC District 1, with local schools including PS 110 (Florence Nightingale), PS 184 (Shuang Wen), and PS 134 (Henrietta Szold). Several daycares are within one mile.

Worship: A diverse mix of churches and synagogues nearby — mostly within a 10-minute walk.

Pharmacies: Local pharmacies are clustered along Grand and East Broadway, including CVS. (Get to that CVS early, though, as it could take you 30 minutes to get a script filled.)

Hospitals: NYU Langone, Bellevue, and NY-Presbyterian are all within approximately one mile.

Transit Access: The F train (East Broadway) is three blocks away, with the B/D/J/Z lines, M9/M14 buses, and the NYC Ferry nearby. There’s also Citi Bike access directly outside.

Pizza: Plenty of pizza options nearby, with the best slice found at Grand Street Pizza or Scarr’s.

Of course, no neighborhood assessment would be complete without considering what’s happening immediately outside the building.

At the time of this analysis, residents can also enjoy construction noise, traffic congestion, and frustrated drivers from the East Side Coastal Resiliency project, which is approaching its sixth year of (visible) work. It remains to be seen how long the area near One Manhattan Square, which is directly across from where construction vehicles are housed, will be affected.

So, the building has amenities. The neighborhood has amenities. And the surrounding infrastructure has its own set of considerations.

But what does the real estate market have to say?

Eight Years of Sales: What Are Buyers Actually Paying?

Since opening in 2018, the Average Unit Price (AUP) has generally declined — until 2025.

Here’s what I’m seeing:

  • 2018: $2,363,000 average unit price | $2,044/SqFt
  • 2019: $1,797,268 average unit price | $2,057/SqFt
  • 2020: $2,100,524 average unit price | $1,971/SqFt
  • 2021: $1,864,093 average unit price | $1,777/SqFt
  • 2022: $1,801,819 average unit price | $1,791/SqFt
  • 2023: $1,654,562 average unit price | $1,777/SqFt
  • 2024: $1,567,930 average unit price | $1,567/SqFt
  • 2025: $1,591,610 average unit price | $1,642/SqFt

What does the uptick mean?

  • Perhaps only more premium units remain.
  • The market may be correcting post-COVID.
  • Or perhaps price per square foot doesn’t tell the full story.

And that last possibility is worth exploring.

After all, we're not comparing identical apartments. Different layouts, exposures, floors, and views can have a meaningful impact on pricing. Looking at building-wide averages is useful, but it only gets us so far.

To better understand where the value lies, we need to go deeper — examining individual apartment lines and layouts, from studios through three-bedroom residences.

Let's Go to Bed — Room by Room

Let's dive into each bedroom category; grab a pillow, but no napping!

Studios

  • Popular: Lines A, C, and D, e.g., 16A/16C/16D.
  • Premium: Line C ($1.33M), likely due to having Hudson River and Midtown views.
  • Best Value: Line A ($1,075/SqFt), which is among the lowest for studios.

1 BRs

  • Popular: Line K (36 sales), F (32 sales), and M (15 sales).
  • Premium: Line B ($2,038/SqFt, $1.42M average); Lines L, K, and M are also high (starting at $1,900/SqFt).
  • Best Value: Line C ($1.17M, 1,670/SqFt)andLineF(1.25M, ~$1,667/SqFt).

2 BRs

  • Popular: Lines L, K, G, H, J, and D, with 10+ transactions.
  • Premium: Line H (2,171/SqFt)andLineJ(2,030/SqFt), likely due to Harbor/South-facing views.
  • Best Value: Line D (~1.71M,~1,560/SqFt); Line G also comes in below $1,600/SqFt.

3 BRs

  • Popular: Strongest showings from Lines C and N.
  • Premium: Line C (Hudson/North) and Line N (East River) lead in price and $/SqFt.
  • Best Value: Line C boasts large layouts (nearly 1,500 ft²) at ~$1,855/SqFt.

How can you evaluate all of the above?

Brown Harris Stevens’ Manhattan 1Q25 Market Report reveals that the average condo price per square foot in 2025 is $1,458.

In that context, consider the location, the age of the building, the surrounding amenities and access points, and make the call… hopefully, to me.

But there's another variable we haven't yet fully explored, and at One Manhattan Square, it's a big one.

Height.

How Much Is a Better View Worth?

The next question I have is: What is the value of being higher up?

That is — what is the price premium as we examine higher floors?

To address that, I’ve aggregated floors in bands of 10 and looked at the average price increase to jump to the next band. The results are interesting:

  • Floors 01–10: Baseline
  • Floors 11–20: +$105,820
  • Floors 21–30: +$149,150
  • Floors 31–40: +$245,141
  • Floors 41–50: –$85,037
  • Floors 51–60: +$173,629
  • Floors 61–70: +$581,691
  • Floors 71+: +$307,020

Did anyone see that dip between floors 41–50?

That's right — it looks like there's potential value to explore within this range. (Admittedly, I don't know precisely why.) What I can say — particularly for lines A–C — is that these face the Manhattan Bridge, so the prime views emerge above the 40th floor, clearing the bridge traffic from the direct sightline.

Of course, these are averages across floor bands, not controlled comparisons of identical apartments. A difference in the mix of units sold can influence the results. But it's an interesting place to start looking for opportunities.

And the substantial jump between floors 51–60 and 61–70 suggests that buyers may be paying considerably more for residences in the upper reaches of the building.

Oh, what's that? The helicopter is leaving? ("Run, go, get to the chopper!")

So, Is One Manhattan Square a Good Buy?

Let's offer some final observations.

1BRs dominate in overall volume, with most falling between 1.25M–1.42M and 1,700–2,000/SqFt.

2BRs range more widely — from ~$1.65M to over $2.3M, depending on view and line.

Price per square foot generally climbs with better views (line) and higher floors.

East River and Harbor-facing lines (H–M) command a clear premium, especially on higher floors.

Since 2018, there's been a broad decline in average pricing, followed by a modest recovery in 2025, with indications of slight increases in top-tier units and softening at mid-tier levels.

So, is OMS a good buy?

That depends on what you're buying — and why.

The building offers an extensive amenity package, modern construction, impressive views, and access to a neighborhood that continues to evolve. But those benefits come at a price, and not all apartments offer the same value.

The data suggests that buyers should look beyond the building-wide averages and pay close attention to the individual line, layout, floor, exposure, and price per square foot.

There may be opportunities among the more affordable one- and two-bedroom lines, and the pricing anomaly between floors 41–50 deserves a closer look.

As for the higher floors, the views may be spectacular, but whether they're worth the premium is ultimately a question of personal preference — and budget.

That's where understanding the numbers, knowing the neighborhood, and working with someone who can put both into context becomes particularly valuable.

And if you're considering a purchase at One Manhattan Square, I'd be happy to help you make the call.

‍