Who Does Your Real Estate Agent Actually Work For?
Our Subjects Encounter a Listing Agent, a Buyer’s Agent, and a Dual Agent

Buying or selling a home involves a small cadre of people: agents, attorneys, lenders, inspectors, appraisers, managing agents, and occasionally a parent, friend, or nosy neighbor offering unsolicited advice.
But among all of these relationships — some of which are formal, others informal — one of the most important can also be one of the least understood: that of the real estate agent.
In New York, representation isn't simply a matter of who showed you the apartment, who answers your calls, or who seems to be helping you through the transaction. An agent represents a principal, also referred to as a client, and that relationship carries specific responsibilities involving loyalty, confidentiality, disclosure, care, and advocacy.
The distinctions matter. Before a seller tells an agent the lowest price they'll accept — or a buyer reveals how high they're willing to go — they should understand who that agent represents and what responsibilities the agent owes them.
Meet the Suburbskys
Herb and Reba Suburbsky love the Lower East Side. They've raised three children here in a beautiful 2,200-square-foot, three-bedroom condo. It's a full-floor apartment with high ceilings, exceptional light, three bathrooms, a magnificent chef’s kitchen, and enough private outdoor space to make their friends in smaller downtown apartments understandably jealous.
For years, it has been more than enough. But the apartment hasn't gotten smaller. The Suburbskys have gotten bigger.
Their oldest son, the only one born when they moved in, is becoming a promising football player. Their youngest daughter has aspirations of becoming a drum major or a ballerina. The middle child is pretty happy-go-lucky and relatively indifferent, so long as he can get a Roblox fix.
Herb and Reba are people of the suburbs — one from Long Island, the other from New Jersey. Unlike some committed Manhattanites, the prospect of a commuter train doesn't fill them with existential dread, although no one is exactly running toward NJ Transit. Reba wants at least 4,000 square feet, more room for her children to flourish, and Herb wants more golf and fewer shared elevators.
They'd also like to have everyone settled before the beginning of the next school year. So, they decide to sell.
A Client, Not a Customer
The Suburbskys interview several agents, all from big brokerages, and eventually hire one to list their apartment. This decision establishes an agency relationship. Within the agency relationship, the Suburbskys are the principals — more typically referred to as clients. Their agent acts on their behalf within the authority granted by that relationship.
In a typical real estate transaction, the agent is considered a special agent. Despite the terminology, this qualification doesn’t bestow praise. It means the agent has been authorized to perform certain acts for the principal rather than being given unlimited authority to act on the principal's behalf.
The Suburbskys haven't handed over control of their apartment to the agent. Rather, their agent is empowered to market the property, arrange showings, communicate with prospective buyers and their representatives, present offers, provide advice, and negotiate within the authority the sellers provide.
An agent's relationship with a client comes with a set of fiduciary responsibilities that include reasonable care, confidentiality, loyalty, obedience, accounting, and disclosure. In practical terms, though, the Suburbskys should expect their agent to advise them competently, follow their (lawful) instructions, keep them informed, safeguard confidential information, properly account for property or money entrusted to the agent, and — above all — put the sellers' interests ahead of the agent's own.
That doesn't mean simply agreeing with everything the Suburbskys say. If comparable sales suggest listing at $4.75 million and Herb and Reba want to list at $4.995 million, their agent should give them an informed opinion. But ultimately, the sellers decide. Likewise, if a qualified buyer offers $4.6 million and accepting it would mean a quick commission, the agent's responsibility is still to the Suburbskys — not to the fastest possible deal.
Confidentiality is particularly important. Suppose Herb and Reba tell their agent that they'd really like to be in the suburbs before the next school year and are prepared to be flexible on price or timing to make that happen. That's valuable information for their agent to have… but also potentially valuable information for a buyer.
The listing agent can't casually disclose the sellers' negotiating position simply because someone asks how motivated they are. The same applies to the lowest price they'll accept, whether they've already found another home, or how urgently they need to sell.
But confidentiality doesn't mean concealment. If the Suburbskys instead tell their agent that water enters around the corner window in the living room during heavy rain, that's a different kind of information. An agent's obligation to protect a client's confidential negotiating information doesn't permit the agent to knowingly misrepresent or conceal material facts that must be disclosed.
The Suburbskys' desire to move before September concerns motivation and bargaining position; a known condition materially affecting the property raises a different obligation.
The Listing Agent Works For…?
The Suburbskys' agent will interact with plenty of people who aren't the Suburbskys. On weekends, the agent will meet with prospective buyers at open houses. They'll answer questions, provide information about the apartment, communicate with buyers' agents, and possibly make referrals to attorneys, lenders, inspectors, and other brokers.
The agent may be many things: Friendly. Helpful. Knowledgeable. But, unless another agency relationship has been established, the listing agent's client is the seller — the Suburbskys — only.
It’s an important distinction to make because real estate transactions can become conversational very quickly. Picture this:
A buyer walks into an open house. They say, “Ooh, I love this sun-drenched, full-floor apartment! It’s practically curated for my taste!”
They begin talking with the listing agent.
“This is exactly what we've been looking for, and we've been outbid on three apartments already. We could probably stretch to $5 million if it’s the right fit.”
On the surface, this is a perfectly ordinary admission. However, there’s something the buyer should understand: The listing agent does not represent them.
Meet the Lowereasts
Lyle and Lori Lowereast already live in New York City with their young daughter, Sida, but their current two-bedroom apartment is already a squeeze. Sida collects large stuffies — or, rather, implores her folks to remain at the likes of Coney Island and the Feast of San Gennaro festivities until they win the top prize at the Bushel Basket Toss.
They want more space for Sida, her stuffed friends, and possibly more children, but they love P.S. 110 and wish to stay on the Lower East Side. One Sunday afternoon, they head over to an open house.
Lori is drawn to the light and the Dornbracht fixtures. Lyle, leaning into his Neanderthal tendencies, is curious about the Toto Neorest toilets. The 2,200 square feet, three bedrooms, three bathrooms, high ceilings, restaurant-grade kitchen and private outdoor space make it a dream find.
They are without representation.
The door opens to the Suburbskys’ apartment. Lori steps in, looks around, and says, “Ooh, I love this sun-drenched, full-floor apartment! It’s practically curated for my taste!”
Lyle adds: “This is exactly what we've been looking for, and we've been outbid on three apartments already. We could probably stretch to $5 million if it’s the right fit.”
The listing agent is friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful. They show the Lowereasts the terrace, answer questions about the building, and explain the process for making an offer.
But they're not Lyle and Lori’s agent.
A Customer, Not a Client
The Suburbskys are the listing agent's clients. Lyle and Lori, absent a separate agency relationship, are customers.
The listing agent still owes the Lowereasts certain responsibilities. An agent can't knowingly misrepresent material facts or engage in dishonest dealing simply because a buyer isn't the client. But the agent's fiduciary responsibilities run to Herb and Reba.
That becomes important when buyers ask perfectly reasonable questions: How motivated are the sellers? Have they bought something else? Would they take $4.5 million? What's the lowest number that gets this done?
Remember, the listing agent already knows that Herb and Reba would like to move before the next school year and may be flexible on price or timing. Lyle and Lori would probably love to know that. But protecting the Suburbskys' confidential negotiating information is part of the listing agent's job.
The reverse is equally important. Lyle has just told the Suburbskys' agent that he and Lori have already lost three apartments and might stretch to $5 million. That's potentially valuable information — just not necessarily to Lyle and Lori.
Buyers need to understand that information they volunteer about their motivation, financial capacity, urgency, or negotiating position may not be confidential when shared with an agent representing the other side.
This is one of many reasons why having representation is important, as an agent can and should protect your interests.
Enter the Buyer's Agent
To have someone representing their interests, Lyle and Lori engage an agent. Now, the Lowereasts become the principals, or clients, and their buyer's agent assumes fiduciary responsibilities to them.
Their agent can help evaluate comparable sales, assess value, structure an offer, develop negotiating strategy, communicate with the listing agent, and advise them throughout the transaction. More importantly, Lyle and Lori can say (privately, to their agent): “We'd like to offer $4.5 million, but we'd go to $5 million if we absolutely had to,” knowing their agent has a duty to protect their confidential negotiating information.
Now the transaction has two sides and two sets of interests. The Suburbskys want to maximize their price and secure favorable terms. The Lowereasts want to buy the apartment for as little as reasonably possible on terms that work for them. The parties may ultimately want the same outcome — a successful transaction — but they don't necessarily want the same deal.
New Agency. Who dis?
New York's agency disclosure requirements are intended to make these relationships clear. For covered residential transactions, disclosure is tied to what's known as the first substantive contact between an agent and a prospective buyer or seller.
That's significant because substantive contact can happen well before anyone makes an offer. A conversation about a buyer's needs, finances, or interest in a particular property can move beyond casual conversation quickly. The disclosure explains the nature of the agency relationship so the consumer understands whether the agent represents the seller, the buyer, or potentially both.
The disclosure itself isn't an agreement to hire the agent. It's there to tell you who the agent represents — something worth knowing before discussing how badly you want the apartment or how much you're prepared to pay for it.
A listing agent can be knowledgeable, responsive, fair, and extremely helpful to a buyer. But helpful and represented aren't the same thing.
At this point, the arrangement is relatively straightforward: the Suburbskys have their representative and the Lowereasts have theirs. Two clients, two agents, two sets of confidential information, and two fiduciary relationships.
But what happens if Lyle and Lori turn to the listing agent, also a fan of stuffed animals and creative ways to house them in New York City, and ask:
“Can you represent us, too?”
Now the agent who knows the Suburbskys want to move before school starts may also know that the Lowereasts would stretch to $5 million.
One agent. Two clients. Competing interests. Woah!
Two Clients, One Agent
Welcome to dual agency. Dual agency occurs when the same real estate agent represents both the seller and the buyer in the same transaction.
It’s rare, and it’s legal in New York — provided it is properly disclosed and both parties give their informed consent.
But think about what that means in the context of our transaction. The listing agent already knows the Suburbskys would like to move before the beginning of the school year. They’re incentivized to leave. Perhaps, privately, Herb and Reba have acknowledged that while they're asking $4.995 million, there's a number below that they'd happily accept to get the deal done.
Now the same agent learns that the Lowereasts have lost three apartments, love this one, and could stretch to $5 million. Each piece of information would be extraordinarily useful to the other side. And the agent is now primed to represent both.
The Problem With Undivided Loyalty
Ordinarily, an agent owes their client undivided loyalty. A seller's agent advocates for the seller. A buyer's agent advocates for the buyer.
But those interests naturally collide. The Suburbskys want the highest possible price. The Lowereasts want the lowest possible price. Herb and Reba might prefer an earlier closing. Lyle and Lori might need more time. One side may want contingencies that the other would prefer to eliminate.
An agent representing both sides can't provide the same undivided loyalty to each client that two independent agents could provide separately. Nor can the agent freely disclose everything they know.
The agent can't tell the Lowereasts, “Herb and Reba really want to be gone before school starts, and I think $4.7 million gets this done.”
They also can't tell the Suburbskys, “Don't take $4.7 million. Lyle already told me he'd go to $5 million.”
Those are precisely the kinds of confidential facts an agent is ordinarily expected to protect. So while dual agency doesn't eliminate an agent's duties to either client, it necessarily limits aspects of the representation — particularly the undivided loyalty and full disclosure each party might otherwise expect from an agent representing only them. Tricky, right?
Disclosure and Consent
Dual agency can't simply happen because it makes a transaction easier. Both the buyer and seller must understand the relationship and consent to it.
In New York residential transactions covered by the agency disclosure requirements, the parties are presented with a disclosure explaining that a dual agent represents both buyer and seller and therefore cannot provide either party with undivided loyalty.
What’s critical here is consent. The Suburbskys need to know that the person they hired to advocate exclusively for them would now also represent the people trying to buy their apartment. The Lowereasts need to know that the person they're asking for representation already represents the people from whom they're trying to obtain the best possible price and terms.
Both sides can agree to that arrangement, but they should also understand what they're agreeing to.
So What Does the Agent Do?
Let's say the Suburbskys and Lowereasts consent to dual agency. Lyle and Lori offer $4.6 million. Herb and Reba counter at $4.9 million. Now everybody turns to the same agent.
“What do you think we should do?”
That's where the limitations of dual agency become very real. The dual agent can facilitate the transaction, communicate offers and counteroffers, provide factual information, explain the process, and continue performing duties that don't require favoring one client over the other.
But the agent has to be careful about advice that would compromise the interests or confidential information of either party. The dual agent knows things. They just can't necessarily use everything they know to help one client defeat the negotiating position of the other.
For some buyers and sellers, that's perfectly acceptable. They understand the limitations and are comfortable proceeding. Others may prefer independent representation precisely because they want an agent who can advocate exclusively for them.
One Brokerage, Two Agents
There's another version of this situation worth understanding. Suppose the Lowereasts don't ask the listing agent personally to represent them. Instead, they work with another agent at the same brokerage. That doesn't automatically make the underlying agency issue disappear.
New York allows a form of dual agency involving designated sales agents, in which the brokerage's dual agent designates one salesperson or associate broker to represent the seller and another to represent the buyer.
In our case, one designated agent could work with the Suburbskys while another works with the Lowereasts. This allows each family to have a specific agent advocating for them within the transaction, while the brokerage remains involved with both sides. (What a potential win for the brokerage!)
The arrangement still requires appropriate disclosure and informed consent because the designated agents operate within a dual-agency structure. The distinction matters, particularly in New York City, where large brokerages can have hundreds or thousands of agents and it's entirely possible for a buyer and seller to arrive at the same transaction represented by different people working under the same brokerage.
Read Before You Sign
Real estate transactions generate a lot of paperwork, and agency disclosure forms can easily become one more document placed in front of a buyer or seller for signature. They shouldn't be treated that way.
The point isn't merely to collect a signature. It's to make sure everyone understands the relationship. Who represents you? Who represents the other party? Does the same agent represent both of you? Are different agents from the same brokerage involved? What confidential information can your agent protect?
And, perhaps most importantly, whose interests can your agent advocate for without limitation?
Back on the Lower East Side, Herb and Reba still want their 4,000 square feet, a backyard, golf, and fewer shared elevators. Lyle and Lori still want enough room for Sida, her growing collection of stuffed animals, and perhaps another child without leaving the neighborhood they love.
They may ultimately agree on a price. The Lowereasts may get the apartment. The Suburbskys may get their suburban home. Everybody may walk away delighted.
But whether you're buying or selling, there's one question worth answering before you start revealing how badly you want the deal: Who does your agent actually work for?



