Why Craigslist Is Still NYC’s Most Dangerous (Sub)Rental Marketplace

The Scam That Nearly Undid a Lower East Side Household

September 5, 2025

Recently, I was helping a neighbor, trying to assist her in finding a four-month sublet this fall while she renovates her co-op. To do this, I combed through many of the known (and possibly unknown) listing outlets, e.g., Sublet.com, LeaseBreak, BlueGround, Rumors.com, as well as Airbnb and VRBO. Oh, and Craigslist.

Finding temporary housing in New York isn't hard, necessarily, but specific situations can make the search more or less challenging — particularly if you’re not looking to become someone’s roommate. Her case was one of the more difficult.

She’s got:

  • A teenage son
  • Two cats
  • An adult significant other who’s in the picture (but not necessarily the lease)

And she’s looking for a pet-friendly, two-bedroom, one-bath apartment without existing roommates for four months. Plus, she had an additional requirement: Proximity.

Her son (understandably) needs to be close to his school, and she needs to be close to work — which is also in the neighborhood. Plus, she needs to be close by to keep tabs on renovation progress on her existing apartment.

Spoiler alert: This story is not going to be about the search or whether we landed her a spot. It’s about the journey and what we encountered.

Among the listings, I found a few on Craigslist well below the price points of the other platforms. They looked clean, had photos, and looked legit. So we inquired.

The name listed was that of a broker. I reached out via Craigslist’s masked email relay, and the broker responded.

First red flag: the grammar was… off. Not what you’d expect from a native speaker, but also not what you’d expect from a bot and an outright scam: just off.

Here’s an example from a response:

“Could you please provide me with your direct contact email address for more information about the apartment? And guide you through our application process. I will be looking forward to read back from you again.”

Maybe “I will be looking forward to read back from you again” is just an auto-correct error?

While that gave me pause, everything else was in order. But, to be safe, I asked for his real estate license number.

He replied fast. Gave the credentials. I checked the NYS Department of State directory — and his name and license number matched up.

Encouraged, I asked for more photos. He sent them, along with a video walkthrough of one of the unit’s interiors. Everything looked better than the listing, including additional vantage points that weren’t included in the stills from the listing.

“Okay, this is promising,” I thought. But then… another red flag.

The broker had a 917 number, so I called him to touch base. He had a foreign accent. This was enough to forgive the grammatical error in his email response. Yet, when I looked up his license info, I found listings tied to a Western New York area code.

Huh?

I pulled up LinkedIn and searched for him. The person I looked up was definitely a broker, and his profile pic matched that of those on one of the listing sites, only all of his properties were for Western New York, where he was seemingly based.

Plus, the LinkedIn profile pic didn’t, shall we say, look like a person who had the same accent as the person with whom I spoke?

So, I called the 917 number again and asked straight up: “It looks like you’re licensed and practicing in Western New York?” He replied: “Oh, I moved.”

Hmm. I wasn’t buying it. So I called the Western New York number listed alongside the Western New York property listings. Worst case, I could apologize for calling the same guy’s other line.

Only a different guy picked up.

Me: “I’m looking at some listings I believe you have in the New York metro area…”

Him (cutting me off): “I’ll stop you there. Someone’s stolen my identity.”

He explained he’d already reported it to the Department of State and the Real Estate Board of New York (REBNY), NYC’s real estate trade association. No one’s been able to take the scammer down. He’s stealing deposits from renters after fake showings.

And just like that, my suspicions were confirmed. I thanked him, hung up, and blocked the fraud. (While I won’t disclose names, mostly to protect the legit broker, I can confirm that the scammer’s listings have since been pulled from Craigslist.)

The lesson?

Without careful checks — license verification, cross-referencing phone numbers, diving into online profiles — my neighbor could have been scammed out of thousands. This is exactly why working with a licensed, local real estate professional matters. Scammers prey on anyone who doesn’t know how to vet them.

Be safe out there. And if you ever need someone to help navigate these waters, I’m here.