Pulling Up Daisy’s in the Garden State or Staying Put in Manhattan?
The Thomas Family’s Real Garden Estate Adventure

Emily Thomas grew up in New Jersey (and we won't hold that against her). She's a young mom with an infant son, a full-time career, and a vision for the life she wants — and deserves — to lead.
As childcare and career begin to overlap (read: blur into one nonstop to-do list), Emily's starting to picture a future where family is just a little bit closer. That might mean help with daycare pickup, an extra hand when school's closed — and school always seems to be closed — or a grandparent on deck when the baby's sick. In other words, the crucial moments that make working parenthood possible.
Now, her partner's parents live in the city, but as Emily puts it, there's really no substitute for her mom, the one who knows everything best. The one she trusts. The one who raised her. (I mean… moms just know, right?)
Her partner's parents are still in the city, and she's growing accustomed to their somewhat hands-off grandparenting style. Perhaps it's just time for a frank conversation? Or perhaps Emily has simply reached that moment when she's trying to overcome a snowbank with an infant-filled stroller. IYKYK.
All of this to say: the Thomases, like our friends the Garcias (re: The Great $1M Tradeoff series), are thinking about the suburbs.
Emily works at 1 Penn Plaza, an easy Midtown West spot by MSG. This is a convenient place to catch the subway or commuter rail. (Yes, it would also open the door to Long Island, but let's not go there now.)
Here's what we know about the Thomases, their credentials, and their criteria:
- Budget: Around $1M with a little wiggle room
- Credit: Excellent
- Down payment: 20%
- Mortgage: 30-year fixed, 5.875%
- Preferred New Jersey Transit line: Northeast Corridor
To help the Thomases through this important process, we've run a similar exercise to our previous Westchester edition, The Great $1M Tradeoff, only this time, we're heading west, into New Jersey, along the Northeast Corridor line. Every fifteen minutes (or roughly so), we're stopping to see what life — and real estate — looks like there.
We're embarking on the Real Garden Estate Adventure — that's a 7-out-of-10 reference to this 2004 film — starting from Midtown West, heading out to Hamilton, and ending back up on the Lower East Side. (Hey, we got the best pickles!)
And, naturally, while we're always happy to humor the would-be suburbanites, we can't help but believe that the greatest value, potential, and richness of life reside right here on the Lower East Side. (That's me, declaring an interest!)
True, every buyer is unique — shaped by their own mix of heartstrings, wallet strings, and family ties. But we'll look at each property objectively, weighing commute time, total cost, and the constants that truly define value.
Property #1: Midtown West — 340 West 55th Street #7B
340 West 55th Street #7B is a 1,023-square-foot co-op in Midtown West (Hell's Kitchen), offering two bedrooms and two bathrooms.
We're starting with a walk-to-work option before heading into the Garden State. This property offers three sides of window exposure, a shared rooftop deck, and a minimal commute, with a prime Midtown West location near Bad Roman.
Property details
- Bedrooms: 2
- Bathrooms: 2
- Square footage: 1,023
Commute breakdown
- Location: Midtown West, New York
- Train stop: NYC Subway (E at 50th Street)
- Walk to NYC Subway: Approximately 7 minutes
- NJ Transit train ride: 0 minutes
- Total monthly commute time: 13.2 hours
- Monthly commuter cost: $132.00
The commute assumes a six-minute walk to the subway station at West 50th Street, a seven-minute train ride, followed by a five-minute walk to the office. This comes out to 13.2 hours per month.
Financial summary
- List price: $999,999
- Monthly mortgage (P&I): $4,732.00
- Monthly maintenance/common charges: $2,930.00
- Utilities, HOA, and other overhead: $200.00
- Total monthly cost (all-in): $7,994.00
Pros: Three sides of window exposure, a shared rooftop deck, and a minimal commute with a prime Midtown West location near Bad Roman.
Cons: Above-average all-in monthly cost while living in a co-op (which can be restrictive), and it doesn't address the expressed longing to be closer to family.
Property #2: Newark Penn — 632 Belgrove Drive, Kearny
Take a breath and brace yourself: it's time to transition to the world of Bridge & Tunnel and visit our first property, located just outside Newark, NJ.
632 Belgrove Drive, Kearny, NJ 07032 is a 3,709-square-foot home offering six bedrooms and six bathrooms.
Property details
- Bedrooms: 6
- Bathrooms: 6
- Square footage: 3,709
Commute breakdown
- Location: Newark (Essex County)
- Train stop: Newark Penn (NJ Transit)
- Drive to station: Approximately 14 minutes (3.3 miles)
- NJ Transit train ride: 20 minutes
- Total monthly commute time: 28.60 hours
- Monthly commuter cost: $528.22
The commute factors in a 14-minute drive to the train station, a 20-minute train ride, followed by a five-minute walk to the office. This comes out to 28.6 hours per month. Also, we're assuming that parking is free (which it isn't), or that the vehicle magically disappears until the return trip.
Financial summary
- List price: $999,000
- Monthly mortgage (P&I): $4,728.00
- Monthly property taxes: $1,293.50
- Utilities, HOA, and other overhead: $680.00
- Total monthly cost (all-in): $7,229.72
Pros: First things first… SPACE! The Kearny property provides 2,600 additional square feet compared with the first property, a difference of more than $700 per square foot. That's baby bedrooms, playrooms, game rooms, TV rooms, libraries, and more!
Cons: Beyond the adjustment to the suburbs, the property is on the corner by the traffic light. Some people might like having two-sided access, but I'm seeing it as a con here since it's not tucked away within an enclosed neighborhood or development. We'll have to ask the Thomases!
Additionally, the aesthetic is rather specific, so if the current style doesn't match Emily & Co.'s taste, they should plan on spending above and beyond list price and closing costs to get it ready.
Property #3: North Elizabeth — 216 West 6th Avenue, Roselle
We're traveling to the North Elizabeth train station, where we'll see the next property.
216 West 6th Avenue, Roselle, NJ 07203 is a single-family residence in Union County, offering eight bedrooms and four bathrooms.
Property details
- Bedrooms: 8
- Bathrooms: 4
Commute breakdown
- Location: Elizabeth (Union County)
- Train stop: North Elizabeth (NJ Transit)
- Drive to station: Approximately 11 minutes (2.7 miles)
- NJ Transit train ride: 31 minutes
- Total monthly commute time: 34.47 hours
- Monthly commuter cost: $539.92
The commute factors in an 11-minute drive to the train station, a 31-minute train ride, followed by a five-minute walk to the office. This comes out to 34.47 hours per month. Again, we're assuming that parking is free (which it isn't), or that the vehicle magically disappears until the return trip.
Financial summary
- List price: $999,000
- Monthly mortgage (P&I): $4,728.00
- Monthly property taxes: $1,887.50
- Utilities, HOA, and other overhead: $680.00
- Total monthly cost (all-in): $7,835.42
Pros: Nearly half an acre with eight bedrooms and a driveway that can fit seven or more cars! What that tells me, unless the Thomases are car people, is that there's space for other projects, like gardens, pools, and fire pits.
Cons: This is an example of a property that does not show well because it appears to have been poorly staged in the photos. This is a con for the sellers, but it's also why I've included it as an option. If the Thomases have a similar aesthetic to me, they'll have to put in money to update and refresh this home.
Property #4: Rahway — 150 Carolyn Avenue, Colonia
Cue the Frank Sinatra. (No, not New York, New York.) We're playing I Did It, Rahway, because that's where the Thomases are headed. Although, given that it's Halloween, perhaps something on this playlist is more appropriate.
150 Carolyn Avenue, Colonia, NJ 07067 sits on an 8,000-square-foot lot and offers five bedrooms and three bathrooms.
Property details
- Bedrooms: 5
- Bathrooms: 3
- Lot size: 8,000 square feet
Commute breakdown
- Location: Rahway (Union County)
- Train stop: Rahway (NJ Transit)
- Drive to station: Approximately 8 minutes (2.3 miles)
- NJ Transit train ride: 45 minutes
- Total monthly commute time: 42.53 hours
- Monthly commuter cost: $578.11
Financial summary
- List price: $1,100,000
- Monthly mortgage (P&I): $5,206.00
- Monthly property taxes: $1,310.83
- Utilities, HOA, and other overhead: $680.00
- Total monthly cost (all-in): $7,774.94
Pros: Large, clean, accessible property in excellent condition, judging by the staging photos.
Cons: While this property has plenty to offer, looks to be in good shape, and was nicely staged, the sellers are looking for an 83% return on their 2018 investment. I will defer to the local real estate professionals advising them with knowledge of the market in Rahway (or Colonia, specifically), but as the Thomases' agent, I would actively review area comps to ensure that this appreciation has occurred with like properties and that the prospective buyers will be strongly positioned for future benefits.
Also, the listing says that it's located in the "desirable" Woodbridge Township School District. I reviewed, and the school system is rated below average (on this site). Take that for what it's worth, as it's only one source, but I'm told that school is important.
Property #5: Edison — 12 Edgewood Road
There's a big election coming up. How will you cast your vote? Will the Thomases choose New Jersey, Midtown West, or the Lower East Side? (What, is that not the election you thought I was referring to?)
Emily Thomas is a Bruce Springsteen-lovin' momma who's On Fire for the Glory Days and has a Hungry Heart to take a Downbound Train to catch a Pink Cadillac to the Badlands of the Garden State. (Yep, lots of commuting.)
But her still-unnamed partner is Out in the Street, ready to Prove It All Night that there's No Surrender on New York. (C'mon, people, don't pull some Tenth Avenue Freeze-Out. I'm doing this to illustrate that More For LES is all about the Human Touch.)
Anyway, Emily is feeling the Boss vibes and is thinking that they might want to try out New Jersey. Today, we're out in Edison, named after our friend with the lightbulb.
12 Edgewood Road, Edison, NJ 08820 is a 3,014-square-foot home in Edison Township, Middlesex County.
Property details
- Bedrooms: 5
- Bathrooms: 4
- Square footage: 3,014
Commute breakdown
- Location: Edison Township (Middlesex County)
- Train stop: Edison (NJ Transit)
- Drive to station: Approximately 18 minutes (4.6 miles)
- NJ Transit train ride: 64 minutes
- Total monthly commute time: 63.80 hours
- Monthly commuter cost: $973.89
Financial summary
- List price: $1,119,999
- Monthly mortgage (P&I): $5,300.00
- Monthly property taxes: $1,565.58
- Utilities, HOA, and other overhead: $680.00
- Total monthly cost (all-in): $8,519.47
Pros: Can we get away with saying "space" again? This colonial home has gorgeous features, lots of windows (and light), and plenty of outdoor green space. It's close to New Brunswick, which has a happening downtown — hello, Rutgers and college kids and tailgating. It also has four baths, which makes it all the cozier for the family and any guests.
Cons: At more than 63 hours of commuting per month, the local traveling will consume almost three days per month (and more than one month per year)... and that's if the trains are always on time!
Property #6: Jersey Avenue — 10 Julie Court, Somerset
The Thomases are venturing deeper into New Jersey today — this time to Somerset, land of the big red "R." Those R's aren't for real estate, royalty, or raconteurs — they're for Rutgers, the State University of New Jersey. A fun local fact, sure, but not necessarily relevant to the Thomases' home search.
Emily, whom we've already met, is a new mom and a career builder at a crossroads. Everything in her life is pulling in different directions. Will moving farther out offer the calm and breathing room she's been craving, or will it pull her too far from the colleagues, community, and city energy that fueled her rise?
10 Julie Court, Somerset, NJ 08873 is a 4,924-square-foot home in Middlesex County.
Property details
- Bedrooms: 4
- Bathrooms: 4
- Square footage: 4,924
Commute breakdown
- Location: New Brunswick (Middlesex County)
- Train stop: Jersey Avenue (NJ Transit)
- Drive to station: Approximately 13 minutes (5.2 miles)
- NJ Transit train ride: 76 minutes
- Total monthly commute time: 68.93 hours
- Monthly commuter cost: $1,144.52
Financial summary
- List price: $999,000
- Monthly mortgage (P&I): $4,728.00
- Monthly property taxes: $1,214.08
- Utilities, HOA, and other overhead: $680.00
- Total monthly cost (all-in): $7,766.60
Pros: Expansive home with vaulted ceilings and skylights, a dual-sided gas fireplace, along with a furnished basement and theater room. Also, the roof is fairly new. When it comes to buying a home — including apartments — it's a useful exercise to evaluate what might need repairs soon, as no one wants to dip into the Rainy Day Fund to fix a roof shortly after moving in.
Cons: After removing the mounted deer head, the Thomases will want to revisit their color palette — this home features more than a few accent walls. Emily and her family, of course, may be into taxidermy and vivid colors, and that's their prerogative. However, were I advising the sellers, I'd probably suggest they cull back some of their aesthetic choices to help more prospective buyers see themselves living there.
Finally, at nearly 69 hours per month commuting, that's close to 34 days per year. (Better get a seat on that train, Emily!)
Property #7: Hamilton — 36 Birdie Way, Lawrenceville
Today, the Thomases see the last New Jersey property on their Real Garden Estate Adventure. The property's in Lawrenceville, childhood home of The Daily Show's Jon Stewart. (Note: They will not be seeing said home.)
As the demands of work, parenting, and daily life line up, the dominoes continue to fall, and Emily's tired of the games. When will she get a respite? (Shhhh. Nobody say: "In 18 years.")
Her partner's parents are in the city, and she is still growing accustomed to their hands-off grandparenting style. (Perhaps it's just time for a frank conversation?)
36 Birdie Way, Lawrenceville, NJ 08648 is a 2,837-square-foot townhouse in Mercer County.
Property details
- Bedrooms: 3
- Bathrooms: 3
- Square footage: 2,837
Commute breakdown
- Location: Lawrenceville, NJ (Mercer County)
- Train stop: Hamilton (NJ Transit)
- Drive to station: Approximately 8 minutes (5.2 miles)
- NJ Transit train ride: 101 minutes
- Total monthly commute time: 83.6 hours
- Monthly commuter cost: $1,235.69
Financial summary
- List price: $949,000
- Monthly mortgage (P&I): $4,491.00
- Monthly property taxes: $1,349.92
- Utilities, HOA, and other overhead: $1,259.00
- Total monthly cost (all-in): $8,335.61
Pros: Bright, airy, multi-level townhouse with gorgeous hardwood floors, a thoughtful layout, marble countertops, Monogram appliances, and a 30,000-square-foot clubhouse that features a pool, tennis and pickleball courts, a fitness center, and on-site dining.
In many ways, this setup is quite similar to a city condo or co-op with luxury services included. However, if the Thomases don't want a clubhouse, tennis courts, or on-site dining, that's more than $700 per month in HOA fees that they will eat, along with 40+ days per year commuting.
Property #8: The Lower East Side — 530 Grand Street #E8C
530 Grand Street #E8C at Hillman Housing Cooperative is our Lower East Side alternative and the final property on the Real Garden Estate Adventure.
We've traveled from Midtown West through New Jersey, stopping along the Northeast Corridor to see what approximately $1 million can buy. We've considered properties with more bedrooms, more bathrooms, more land, and more amenities, along with the financial and commuting commitments that come with them.
And now we're back on the Lower East Side, where I believe the greatest value, potential, and richness of life reside. This is More For LES's preferred alternative to the other properties we've considered, and I've declared my interest from the beginning.
Of course, every buyer is unique, shaped by their own mix of heartstrings, wallet strings, and family ties. Emily's desire to be closer to her mother is real, and there's no substitute for the help and support she trusts. But the Thomases must also weigh commute time, total cost, and the constants that truly define value.
Which would you choose?
Methodology
The methodology below details the criteria and assumptions used for comparing eight real estate properties in New Jersey and New York City. The goal is to set a consistent baseline for evaluating which property offers the best overall value — a combination of affordability, space, and minimal time burden — for the Thomases.
The analysis focuses on properties accessible via the New Jersey Transit (NJT) Northeast Corridor Line, segmented by proximity to Midtown, and includes two New York City co-ops, including one on the Lower East Side.
Property Selection and Constraints
- Price constraint: Properties were identified to be priced at, under, or near $1,000,000. A few properties in the final analysis exceeded the $1M mark, but the criteria were maintained for the overall property search, with a $1M (or less) closing price achievable for all.
- Availability: At the time of selection, each property was current and available.
- Property types: The analysis includes co-ops (NYC) and single-family homes.
Transit Proximity and Access
- Final destination: All commutes end at One Penn Plaza (via NY Penn Station or a nearby subway stop).
- Final leg of commute: The walk from the transit exit (train or subway) to One Penn Plaza is assumed to be five minutes for all properties.
- Proximity mode: Properties are classified by the Thomases' assumed mode of transit to the station: walking or driving. In New York, all commutes to/from the subways are walked, while in New Jersey all commutes to/from the trains are driven.
Transit Framework and Temporal Cost
- NJ Transit segments: NJ properties are grouped around 15-minute train-ride increments along the Northeast Corridor Line.
- Train time (NJ): The actual ride length is based on the reported schedule time for a local train.
- Subway time (NYC): The actual ride length is assumed to be either five minutes (Midtown West) or 15 minutes (Lower East Side) to reach the subway stop closest to Penn Plaza.
- Punctuality: All trains and subways are assumed to run on time — no delays. (Shah, right, NJ Transit! Also, shah, right, MTA!)
- Commute frequency: The analysis assumes 22 working days per month.
- Temporal cost: This is just a fancy way of saying that we calculated the total number of hours spent commuting per month, added them up, and reported back.
Commute Cost Assumptions
- NYC subway pass: Commuting cost is based on a monthly MetroCard fee of $132.
- NJ Transit pass (estimated): Cost is based on a proportional scaling method, with Hamilton Station's published monthly rate of $547 serving as the 100% benchmark.
- Proportional scaling: Other stations are priced at fixed percentages of the Hamilton rate: 16.67%, 50%, 66.67%, and 83.33%. These figures are provided to give us some cost measure, assuming that monthly cards increase in cost the longer the train legs.
- Driving cost (NJ properties only): The cost for the driving portion of the commute is calculated using a gas price of $3.01 per gallon. The total monthly driving cost accounts for a full 22 working days per month (round trip) and is added to the NJT monthly pass price.
- No taxis! We are not taking any taxis on this voyage.
Monthly Overhead and Financial Assumptions
The monthly overhead is normalized to reflect the true all-in cost of carrying the property, excluding commuting costs.
- Mortgage rate: A 5.875% interest rate for a 30-year fixed mortgage is assumed for calculating the monthly principal and interest (P&I) payment.
- Down payment: The Thomases will put 20% down.
- Monthly maintenance: For NYC properties (both co-ops), the amount of monthly maintenance charges is stipulated in the listing and the specific property post.
- NYC utilities: For NYC properties, $200 is allocated for internet and electricity. The rest is covered in the specific maintenance fee.
- NJ overhead: For NJ properties, the amount of monthly property taxes is stipulated in the listing and the specific property post. Fees for electricity, heating, water/sewer, and internet are estimated at $530 per month, regardless of the property.
- HOA dues: No HOA dues are included in the NYC properties. In NJ, one property has an HOA fee of $729 per month. The rest of the NJ properties do not have listed HOA fees; however, we are assuming $150 per month for these.
Nature of the Estimates
The resulting figures are illustrative, best-case examples intended solely for a comparative analysis of the eight properties, setting a consistent baseline to determine the best financial and temporal value for the Thomases.
The full methodology is also available here.



